By any measure of Italian culture, it was a miracle.

Back in September, I invited some 20 gay guys to my apartment to celebrate my first year in Italy, and basically every single one of them showed up. I expected that maybe a handful of them would come—which would have been more than enough for my small home! But instead, my living room overflowed with friends occupying every crevice.

I was shocked and delighted that so many people came to celebrate with me. And I was inspired to keep the momentum going.

Why not make this a monthly occurrence? A low key potluck for whoever wanted to swing through each time? Buoyed by the warm-and-fuzzies of seeing my home filled with so many sweet pals, I resolved to plan another get-together as soon as I could.

This isn’t a paywall, but before you keep reading… Can you help sustain Finocchio? This project isn’t my side hustle, it’s my main focus of work and, with your help, it’s becoming my main source of income. I rely on paid subscribers to keep this newsletter going. You can subscribe for just a few bucks a month, and that support literally helps pay my rent. It also gets you the rest of this juicy article, and many more stories on both taboo topics and heartfelt moments from my queer life in Italy.

A couple weeks later, I was on a hike with my usual group of homosexuals, which included a few of the friends who came to my party, when I started floating my idea for the next brunch.

I wasn’t just any Sunday luncheon that I wanted to host. No, I was dreaming of something gayer: A butt-naked banquet.

As we climbed through the rocky green hills of Northern Italy, I mentioned it to one friend, then another. ā€œIf I hosted a clothing-optional potluck at my place, would you come through?ā€ They all said yeah, probably. My proposed date, just a week later, seemed to work for them, too.

So, I returned to the group chat and announced my gathering for early October. I asked my would-be guests to arrive with a plate to share and clothes they were willing to shed at the door.

A few early ā€œno’sā€ rolled in, but a then a couple friends said they’d try to make it. I was cautiously optimistic. When the day arrived, however, it was looking like just one person could come, and I was struggling to beat a cold, so I called it off. I’d propose a new date in November with plenty of advance notice, and surely a few people would come then.

I did just that, giving the gays of the group chat a whole month to pencil me in their calendar. I was not expecting a full house—I know social nudity is not for everyone—but I had seen most (if not all) of these friends naked already, so that didn’t feel like a huge barrier.

But as the weeks rolled on, the RVSPs stayed empty. When I made a last call a few days before, the chat filled with ā€œI’m sorry’sā€ and ā€œnext time’s.ā€ The naked brunch had died once again. Rest in Peace.

The experience of trying and failing (twice!) to organize this little shindig was more than a little demoralizing.

It dredged up all sorts of insecurities about not being loved and wanted. (Classic!) I don’t blame my friends, really. But I did start to wonder if my September soiree was a fluke, never to be repeated again.

It’s a common lament of millennial adulthood that making plans can feel absolutely impossible. Sometimes nothing short of a Doodle poll and a calendar invite is required to get a group of friends together. And even then, you’re often resigned to the dreaded ā€œcatch up,ā€ gone are the days of actually doing anything together.

In Italy, I’ve had a bit more luck. I find that Italians are a usually more spontaneous, not so overly-scheduled. You can hit up a friend and grab an aperitivo that very night, most of the time. And inviting someone to an event more than a couple weeks away? Fuhgeddaboudit. Italians are not thinking that far ahead.

So I didn’t think it was out of the question to throw a brunch a week away and get a few friends to my apartment. When it failed, I reverted to my American ways and gave a month’s notice. But that failed, too.

Maybe the fatal flaw was the no-textile policy. This is quite possible, loathe as I am to admit it. ĀÆ\_(惄)_/ĀÆ But is it really too much to ask to have a little clothing-optional conclave every once in a while??

Apparently so.

I know my friends love me. I know some of them genuinely wanted to come (let it all) hang out with me, scheduling conflicts notwithstanding. And yet, I’m still feeling a little bruised by it all.

When I was texting friends individually in the days before my second failed brunch, trying to rally attendance, I hesitated, feeling like maybe I was doing that bad-friend thing where I only reach out when I need something.

I guess in a sense, I did need (or at least want) something from them. But I wasn’t asking for a ride to the airport. What I needed was a couple of hours, on a Sunday afternoon, relaxing in the warmth of friendship.

šŸ“ø Finocchio Foto

This week, I leave you with a photo from a spooky late-fall hike.

Photo by Mike De Socio

Reply

Avatar

or to participate

Keep Reading